Matthew Schaefer is the story on Long Island. The 19-year-old, taken first overall, put together one of the great rookie defenseman seasons in NHL history, winning the Calder Trophy with 23 goals and 59 points and cementing himself as a franchise cornerstone. Around him, Mathew Barzal (72 points) drives the offense and Bo Horvat chipped in 31 goals, while Ilya Sorokin was one of the best goaltenders in the league, ranking second in the NHL in goals saved above expected. And yet the Islanders missed the playoffs in a brutal Metro race, a reminder that the supporting cast still has to catch up to the top of the roster. This summer brought change up front, with longtime captain Anders Lee leaving for Utah and veteran Brayden Schenn brought in down the middle. The pieces of a real team are here, led by a generational teenager on the back end, and the front office has to build enough around Schaefer, Barzal, and Sorokin to turn talent into a playoff berth.

The New York Islanders have $6.0M in salary cap space for the 2026-27 season, with $98.0M committed against the $104.0M cap (94% utilization).
Mathew Barzal is the New York Islanders' highest-paid player with a $9.15M cap hit, signed through 2031.
The New York Islanders have 23 players signed toward the 23-man active roster (roster full).
The New York Islanders' top cap hits for 2026-27 are Mathew Barzal ($9.15M), Bo Horvat ($8.5M), Ilya Sorokin ($8.25M).
Regular-season points, last five seasons.
Closest historical team-seasons by points pace, goals for, and goals against (era-normalized z-score, since 1967–68). Click any card to open a side-by-side compare.
1 selection in rounds 1-3. Prospect pages; NHL roster spots come as they sign.
Free forever. No credit card.
Make a Free Account and gain